The Strategic Planning Lie That’s Keeping Banks Mediocre [VIDEO]
Roxanne Emmerich exposes the toxic lie behind most strategic plans—and the second-order thinking top banks use to pull away from the pack.

Research shows that just a few lenders, usually about 6% that have a business development profile, carry the rest. Moreover, even that happens only if that 6 % know how to implement the right sales process. Otherwise, those naturally gifted lenders sell only by matching rates, which is hardly impressive.
After these three steps play out, typically, the fourth step is often triggered: repeating the first three hoping maybe it will work next time.
Nobody knows other strategies that work, so some version of the three “steps” shows up on strategic plans for most banks nationwide nearly annually – always hoping for different results.
It’s not your fault. Those strategies certainly sound as if they would be “common sense.”
But if those three steps don’t work, then what does?
Let’s look at banks that consistently attain NIM of over five and/or ROA of over 2.
Success does leave clues.
Team selling with team composition dictated by emotional assessment scores is a common practice of these high-performing banks. Their results require consistently hitting growth goals for both loans and deposits with premium pricing on quality prospects. Anyone can close loans with desperate prospects. True mastery is earning premium pricing on the most desirable prospects in your market –after all, getting premium pricing is why sales positions exist.
First, as mentioned, only 6% of people have an emotional intelligence profile that correlates with attracting significant new business without giving up rate. Emotional intelligence is essentially thinking that happens before predictable behaviors.
It is like having long limbs and quick reflexes that provide the potential to be a great basketball player: The individual must still learn to play but certainly has a much higher chance to succeed.
You can try the stick of threatening to put a lender on a performance plan, the carrot of incentive pay, or any other trick. However, only about 6% have long limbs, height, and speedy reflexes that give them a chance to make the NBA.
This doesn’t mean you should fire the other 94%. Those with other profiles seem to sell very well on teams using a tightly structured and well-executed sales process designed to get premium pricing if they have the minimum profile to be in sales. If not, the cost of mental anguish to them and lost sales to you can be crushing. Given the right role on teams, though, there is a place for every lender –one where they win because synergy means 2+2+2 can equal 20.
Most banks get this all wrong.
They simply connect two people, call them a team, and that doesn’t do much. Alternatively, structuring roles including project manager, account manager, topic expert, present of Level 4 USP, sales lead, etc., allows for the team to function.
The standard you should set should allow for a 90% close rate on those most desirable prospects. If they are below that, it is clear that they are not following the right process with precision. That is a KPI every bank executive team should review weekly — cross sales on Top 100 prospects.
The secret is in their emotional intelligence scores.
With so much at risk, hiring the wrong person can be disastrous. The easiest and most significant ROI decision you can make this year begins with the ZERORISK Hiring System, which will reduce your risk to the lowest possible level. Discover the ZERORISK Hiring System to see how you can start to benefit from this remarkably effective tool today.
Roxanne Emmerich exposes the toxic lie behind most strategic plans—and the second-order thinking top banks use to pull away from the pack.
Your boardroom may be your biggest blind spot. Discover how elite banks fix strategy at the Breakthrough Banking Blueprint™ Bootcamp.
Great employees don’t automatically produce great bank results. Discover why Top 5% performance requires employees who understand profitability, create deeper relationships, command premium pricing, and become trusted advisors customers never want to leave.
Elite banks aren’t born elite. They build systems, practice the right behaviors, and continually sharpen how they create value. Discover what helps top 5% banks reach exceptional performance—and stay there.
What separates America’s top-performing community banks from everyone else? Discover the systems, culture, and performance disciplines that help extraordinary banks protect profitability and independence.
Most banks lose the pricing conversation long before rates are discussed. Discover how elite community banks command premium pricing while protecting profitability and independence.
Most banks never intend to compete on price, yet rate matching quietly erodes profitability every day. Discover the strategy that allows top-performing community banks to command premium pricing and protect net interest margin.
The best community banks don’t win pricing wars—they avoid them. Discover how stronger positioning leads to higher net interest margin and greater profitability.
The highest-performing community banks don’t waste months searching for their ideal customers. Discover the proven process they use to identify profitable relationships quickly and execute with confidence.
Most banks believe their market determines pricing. Discover why that belief destroys profitability—and how elite community banks command premium pricing instead.