The Strategic Planning Lie That’s Keeping Banks Mediocre [VIDEO]
Roxanne Emmerich exposes the toxic lie behind most strategic plans—and the second-order thinking top banks use to pull away from the pack.

In this blog, you’ll discover how you can get far more and more predictable profit and growth impact from your strategic planning process.
After reviewing over 500 strategic plans, I find that many banks lack effective strategies, lack intentional congruence, and essentially have a list of goals, but lack an effective way to get there.
If you’re the kind of leader who:
…You’re going to love this!
Challenge 1:
Most banks have a strategic planning book with a plethora of goals. What’s missing are at least 25 different actual strategies that will bring earth-moving changes that get you paid more for doing business with the most desirable prospects in your market.
In fact, in looking at hundreds of plans over the years, I can honestly say that I’ve not seen more than five total strategies combined in all of the plans. That’s right on hundreds of plans, only a total of five. Also, most plans lack intentional congruence.
Challenge 2:
The big hairy audacious goal or BHAG is not congruent with the psychographics and firmographics of the top two to three target markets, and the key initiatives are a disjointed list of to-dos. There is no alignment. Additionally, the plan doesn’t usually account for an extremely relevant fact.
If you are a normal bank, only 13% of customers are profitable. The problem is it doesn’t have a solid and proven strategy to get more profitable customers just like them and get all the business of that 13% at extreme premium pricing. So even if the plan is executed well, it still puts the franchise value at risk.
Every bank seems to be facing these same problems.
Thousands of strategic plans are lackluster and ineffective without exception. Let’s talk about strategic plans that actually work at bringing in your most profitable prospects and making them your best customers.
Unlike so many strategic planning processes, you must start with understanding the psychographic and firmographic similarities of your top 100 most profitable customers. Then, to make sure your plan is about profit and not about busywork. Ensure that you’ve based the entire thing over no more than three integrated psychographic/firmographic intersections of that group.
Forget everything you learned about strategic planning in school. The old model of mission statements, SWOTS, and goals are ridiculously antiquated. We live in a world of disruption where non-bank vendors are vultures ready to eat the lunch of banks who still think a yearly strategic planning process is enough to drive growth and profitability. Heaven forbid if you are a bank that is doing the “we do strategic planning every two years” approach. Have you ever seen a top 10% performing bank do that? Me neither.
Move to a one -page strategic planning process, but don’t think because it’s brief that it’s easy or quick. If you do it right, it will be 10 times harder, but then you’ll work 100 times smarter all year. You’re packing a lot of punch in that one page with an extreme focus on the few things that matter. Make sure there is intentional congruence so that all of the elements of the plant are working together for an immediate profit boost.
Get everything and everyone on a visible accountability system so that every team member in your organization knows what they need to do every week to align with profit.
Put a strategic plan into place using these elements, and you can relax and know that your plan will be implemented. You will get people away from being busy to being profit-oriented, which dramatically contributes to your bank’s bottom line.
Roxanne Emmerich exposes the toxic lie behind most strategic plans—and the second-order thinking top banks use to pull away from the pack.
Your boardroom may be your biggest blind spot. Discover how elite banks fix strategy at the Breakthrough Banking Blueprint™ Bootcamp.
Great employees don’t automatically produce great bank results. Discover why Top 5% performance requires employees who understand profitability, create deeper relationships, command premium pricing, and become trusted advisors customers never want to leave.
Elite banks aren’t born elite. They build systems, practice the right behaviors, and continually sharpen how they create value. Discover what helps top 5% banks reach exceptional performance—and stay there.
What separates America’s top-performing community banks from everyone else? Discover the systems, culture, and performance disciplines that help extraordinary banks protect profitability and independence.
Most banks lose the pricing conversation long before rates are discussed. Discover how elite community banks command premium pricing while protecting profitability and independence.
Most banks never intend to compete on price, yet rate matching quietly erodes profitability every day. Discover the strategy that allows top-performing community banks to command premium pricing and protect net interest margin.
The best community banks don’t win pricing wars—they avoid them. Discover how stronger positioning leads to higher net interest margin and greater profitability.
The highest-performing community banks don’t waste months searching for their ideal customers. Discover the proven process they use to identify profitable relationships quickly and execute with confidence.
Most banks believe their market determines pricing. Discover why that belief destroys profitability—and how elite community banks command premium pricing instead.