Why Your Team Can’t Charge Premium Pricing—And How It’s Killing Your Legacy [VIDEO] Why Banks Fail at Premium Pricing | Community Bank Strategy

Welcome to the Top 5 Percenter™ Blog

Why Your Team Can’t Charge Premium Pricing—And How It’s Killing Your Legacy [VIDEO]

by | Increase Net Interest Margin, NIM, Premium Pricing

Premium pricing doesn’t break down because of markets or competitors. It breaks down because your people don’t believe you’re worth more.

In this video, Roxanne Emmerich exposes the real constraint behind underpricing: scarcity thinking inside your own institution. You can push incentives, tweak comp plans, and preach value all day—but until belief changes, behavior won’t.

Most banks unknowingly train their teams to think price is a zero-sum game. The result? Discounting, margin erosion, and a slow drift toward commoditization. Top-performing banks operate differently. They understand that affluent clients don’t buy on price—they buy on meaning, differentiation, and confidence.

Here’s what must shift:

  • Belief precedes pricing power—confidence comes before execution

  • Affluent buyers decide based on value, not rates

  • Category-of-one positioning eliminates price pressure altogether

If this problem stays unresolved, it won’t remain contained. It will cost you margin, culture, and eventually your independence.

That’s exactly why Roxanne is teaching this framework live at the Breakthrough Banking Blueprint™ Bootcamp. This is where banks discover how to shift mindset, reposition value, and equip their teams to charge what they’re truly worth—without discounting.

Seats are limited. Register now. 

Watch now. 

My mentor of three decades taught me something about abundance consciousness. He is one of the wealthiest people in this country, and he came to this country with fifty dollars in his pocket. But he showed me a system one time, and when I immediately began to implement the system, it worked.

Some of my colleagues went to him and said, “How is Roxanne doing this? How is she getting all this business at premium pricing?”
And he said to them something I’ll never forget. He said, “She’s ignorant. She doesn’t know she can’t.” Which is one of the best compliments I’ve ever received.

In other words, I’m not going to buy into the story of playing small. I’m not going to buy into the idea that I have to match somebody else’s pricing. I’m not going to play small because the rest of the world is playing small.

And yet, I know as an executive, you’ve got people you’re kicking and pushing and yelling at—doing everything you can with incentive pay. You’re trying the carrot. You’re trying the stick. And you’re getting nowhere getting them to charge premium pricing, because there’s a deeper-level problem.

They don’t believe they can.

There’s scarcity thinking. They think if they receive this, they’re taking it away from that.

They don’t understand that we’re not competing for pieces of the pie—we’re growing the pie. By creating a situation where that bank customer is so much better taken care of that their business thrives, they will make millions as a result of the extra ten thousand dollars that we charge. When our people get that, the magic begins to happen.

You’re going to need to do some lobotomies to help them understand that just because they believe price is the primary decision-making item, the affluent do not.

Most affluent do not buy on price—but they will if you don’t give them alternative information that matters more.

Thus, the correct sales process, built upon a clear differentiator that makes you the one and only—once you become a category of one—you can charge whatever you want.

There are steps along this pathway: defining how you’re different, getting your people some early big wins so they believe they can do it, and once that flywheel is turning, the rest come along too.

So if you’re still living with this problem, you’re not alone. Thousands of bank executives have been where you are.

But you can’t continue to live with this problem. You need a new, fresh problem. This one must be eliminated—because it will cause you to lose the name on your front door. It will take away your legacy. This one must be fixed.

I’ll see you at the Breakthrough Banking Blueprint Bootcamp where I’m going to show you how to get this done—because I can’t stand watching you suffer anymore.

Make sure you check in with me when you get there. I want to get to know who you are and how I can help—because I am committed to every community bank in this country keeping its independence. But you’ve got to be there so I can show you how.

See you there.

More From The Blog

Acquisitions That WORK: The Bomb-Proof Management System That’s Ready to Roll

A lot of bad things happen around acquisitions. If you’re being acquired, it’s rarely pretty. And if you’re the one acquiring, the Wharton School of Business says your chance of failure is greater than 83 percent. And even if you don’t go down in flames in the opening round, the real heartaches continue for two years after the acquisition as two dark forces are inevitably unleashed:

Mergers and Acquisitions: If an Opportunity Falls in Your Lap, Are You Ready?

The coming bank consolidation isn’t a surprise. It’s been predicted for years. In fact, the next 18 months are destined to be a major “shake out” period when weak banks will be acquired or closed—and banks that are in a position to capture the best customers in town will become stronger and more profitable.

Bank Culture: The #1 Predictor of Future Growth and Profitability

Culture asks, “Will your people leap over tall buildings in a single bound to make sure your client is successful in their business or personal financial goals?” “Will you go beyond bank “product” to create Unique Selling Propositions that rock their world and cause hundreds of thousands of dollars of impact for them? And will your people have fun doing it so that your system is sustainable?

Confidence Trumps Sales Training EVERY Time

Thousands of bank executives are waking up to 2013 saying, “SALES training! Of course! It’s SALES training we need.”

Yeah, well sometimes the first thing that pops into our heads isn’t a keeper. Sales training is fine, but it’s NOT what you need to solve your problem and create a sustainable solution.