Welcome to the Top 5 Percenter™ Blog

Most banks do not have an AI problem. They have a thinking problem.

In this week’s video, Roxanne Emmerich challenges bank executives to move beyond first-order thinking—the easy, obvious, defendable answer that rarely fixes the real issue. “We need sales, so let’s get sales training.” “We need deposits, so let’s hire a new head of retail.” Those are pedestrian solutions for a complex, fast-moving environment.

The banks that win the next era will be led by executives who force second-order thinking into the organization before AI accelerates bad assumptions, scattered activity, and expensive misfires.

In this video, you’ll discover:

  • Why simple answers usually fail in complex banking environments
  • How second-order thinking helps executives spot consequences before they become costly
  • Why AI readiness starts with better executive thinking—not more training

If your team is resisting change, waiting for old roles to return, or chasing activity instead of strategy, this is the wake-up call. The future will not reward pedestrian thinking.

Watch now. 

I have a book that I love that I read a couple times last year, and I continue to reference it often. It’s called Intelligent Thinking, which sounds like a pretty good thing to do. And on pages fifty-eight and fifty-nine, there’s the concept of first-order thinking and second-order thinking. And I think it’s important to understand as an executive to make sure that you are using the right thinking and make sure that you’re evolving your people to the right thinking.

Here’s how he defines it. First-order thinkers look for things that are simple, easy, defendable. But, unfortunately, the whole ecosystem we live in is not that simple. Rather, it’s a complex permutation and combination of various factors and their interaction at any given point in time.

Examples of that would be, “We need sales. Let’s get sales training.”

“We need to improve deposits. Let’s get a new head of retail.” First-order thinking, does it ever work?

Maybe one percent of the time. Second-order thinkers go way beyond the simple and look outside, extending to different parameters.

They go to second, third, and subsequent levels of probable consequences and think deeper.

Second-order thinkers think in terms of interactions amongst various factors, with attention to time and system-related aspects. They ask questions like, “What different factors or parameters are involved in this problem, and what’s the interaction? What could be different possible consequences of taking a particular action and analyzing each consequence? How do we leverage to speed up the solutions?”

Charlie Munger says it best when he talks about second-level thinking. He says, “It’s not supposed to be easy. Anyone who finds it easy is stupid.”

Gotta love Charlie Munger. Right? I mean, the guy was one of the most brilliant business minds of our time. And here’s why I think this is an important concept for bank executives to be thinking of right now. In the world of AI, if you don’t have a second order of thinking guiding the direction of things, you will have a whole lot of activity that you find to be going in the wrong direction because everybody came up with their first-order thinking approach, and now suddenly it’s not working.

We have a crisis in the industry right now, and we have a small window of time to elevate the thinking to the next level of thinking. You don’t have a lot of time to figure this out. You gotta get moving here. So it’s not about training programs because training is teaching people what to do. It’s kind of like how to be a monkey. Right?

Education is teaching people how to be, how to think at a deeper level, how to go down deep, and to get rid of the pedestrian solutions and go for deeper-level thinking that actually solves the problems and, more importantly, takes advantage of the opportunities.

Stick with me as we talk about how you are going to take your team and get them ready for this new world of AI while they’re resisting and fighting and saying, “No way, not me. I want my old job,” when you know you cannot guarantee their old job because it’s just not going to continue to exist. Welcome to the world of second-order thinking.

More From The Blog

Simple Secret for Growing Net Interest Margin

You’ve heard it before – the bankers who are STILL calling on clients asking hideously inept questions such as, “What kind of things are you looking for in a bank?” or “Tell me about your business,” or “What kind of things are keeping you up at night?” UGH.

Just say NO to Strategic Planning Land Mines

Is your strategic plan the right plan—and one that can and will get completed?

If you’re like most bankers, you probably pulled your strategic plan together eight or nine months ago. But is everyone in the bank on a weekly process to make sure they all hit the outcomes?

You are hearing everywhere that those who run their banks like they ran them five years ago won’t make it in the not-so-distant future. Heck, based on the news reports over the past year, they may no longer be in business.

Is It Over Yet?

s there anything worse than a bad meeting? Anything? Fine, yes, world hunger, soul-crushing poverty, and violence in the Middle East. But in the midst of a truly bad meeting, it’s easy to convince yourself that all of those problems will be distant memories before the meeting EVER ENDS.

The #1 Reason Bank Acquisitions Fail

 Think you’re ready for an acquisition? Think you’ve got a bullet-proof plan? Imagine if you take a “bring-it-on-and-make-it-happen-no-matter-what” bank culture where...

So What’s Your Story?

“Homework? Ah, yes, I did my homework, but it didn’t quite make it here. Why? Well, my dog ate the homework. We took him to the vet to get the homework back, but the...

Get Paid the Premium Pricing You’re Worth with Critical Drivers that WORK

If you ask commercial lenders how they’re doing, most would say they’re performing strongly. But performance for them too often means sitting in the bank, waiting for B and C credits to walk in, interviewing them, getting their data, sending it to the credit committee—then trying to sell the committee on how to make that loan work, even though it has risks.